Voice From The Nation

Baseball fans have been inundated with Johan Santana talk since the last pitch of the World Series. Rumors have heated up and cooled down. Trade proposals have been leaked and then rigorously debated in the media, blogs, message boards and around the water cooler. Fans of the teams rumored to be involved have agonized over the players named in the discussions and have wrestled with their own internal debates.

The northeast has been hit especially hard by the Santana sweepstakes with both the Red Sox and Yankees prominently involved in the nearly daily tug of war for his services. One day we hear Jon Lester is having a physical and a deal is as good as done for the Red Sox and then the next day we hear the Yankees are very close. With all of the attention, Santana has become more than just a player, he represents the balance of power between these two über teams. For the Yankees, he is the number one starter the team so desperately needs to get back to glory. The final piece of the puzzle that allows Wang and Pettitte to move down in the rotation and suddenly makes the entire pitching staff look significantly better. For the Red Sox, he would be matched up with Beckett, Dice K, Schilling and the young Buckholtz to form one of the greatest rotations in baseball history.

The problems arise when the names rumored to be going to Minnesota are mentioned. For the first time in a very long time both the Red Sox and Yankees have significant prospects coming up through their systems. Both fan bases have embraced these players as a sign of better days ahead for their teams with rosters filled with home grown stars that you can be proud of instead of a contingent of mercenary players for hire.  

As great as Santana would be in the rotation, it would be tough for a Red Sox fan to see some combination of Lester, Ellsbury, Buckholtz, Lowrie or Masterson go in a package to Minnesota. Not to mention the fact that the added $25 million in payroll it would take to sign Santana past 2008 would inflate the Red Sox payroll into dreaded Yankees' territory. It seems safer, wiser and in some ways almost proper not to make the trade.

If the Red Sox do not pull the trigger, the likelihood of the Yankees getting the prized pitcher increases significantly. The Yankees would also have to pine over giving up mega prospects like Phil Hughes and Ian Kennedy as well as good young players like Melky Cabrera in a package that would entice the Twins. Adding Santana to the Yankees with their already unmatched offense and solid pitching would make Red Sons fans shutter.

So where does that leave us? Well, in my opinion, the best-case scenario would be he stays put in Minnnesota or even better he gets traded to the National League. Currently the only National League team that has been mentioned significantly in the trade talks has been the Mets and the general consensus is that they do not have enough to offer to interest Minnesota. But we can dream. In a perfect world we keep the nucleus of the perfect mix of young and veteran players in Boston intact and Santana stays away from the New York (at least, the Yankees). I would take that outcome and then let the chips fall from there in 2008.